Ally Briscoe falls head over heels the first time she sees Bain Duncan, but has no luck in getting the black-haired hunk to notice her. New to the Fort Worth area and now a single man, Bain wants to do his job and be left alone. Getting involved with another woman is at the bottom of his to-do list.

Claudius Ulysses Pervis Ichabod Derryberry — alias Cupid — tells Ally the solution to getting Bain's attention is simple — she has to seduce him. And what better day for that than Valentine's Day?